Jan
Conflict: The Path of Least Resistance Won’t Get You Published
So we’ve discussed goal and motivation. Next up is everybody’s favorite: conflict. Conflict is the unmovable object meeting the unstoppable force. In the case of romance novels it’s a hero and a hero who really don’t want to fall in love fighting that very emotion. Since it’s so vital to plot a lot of authors, particularly new authors, have trouble with it. They don’t want to put their characters through hell, don’t want them to make bad decisions. Let me tell you, Harry Potter would not be the phenomenon it is if Harry had never been attacked by Voldemort, or been brought up by his awful aunt and uncle, or sent off to Hogwart’s to face the challenges there. It is only because of his triumph over adversity that Harry Potter zapped his way into our hearts.
Conflict
• Both external and internal is both internal and external, just like goal and motivation. Internal is inside the character (emotion) – what they want vs what they must do. What they will gain or lose by making a choice. If they aren’t trying to avoid a situation, there is no conflict. Your hero who wants love, but never had it growing up? He must put himself out there to be loved and that’s not easy when you expect to have your heart stepped on. External is the outside problem standing between what the character and his/her goals. It is anything you can see, hear, touch, smell, etc. Tangible while the internal is intangible. External is something that the character can deal with but not necessarily resolve. Goals cannot be abandoned in the face of this obstacle. Your heroine wants to save the family farm because it is her all she has left of her parents. The hero is trying to foreclose on her mortgage.
• A good guideline for new authors is this: your hero (or heroine) wants something for a reason. Make the other character the reason they can’t have it. Or, the only character who can give it to them.
• Conflict is friction. Opposition. It does not mean that your characters have to fight all the time. That’s just annoying. There is nothing sexier than two people who want each other despite having conflicting goals. Eventually they’re going to want to work out the conflict so they can be together. They can’t do that if they’re fighting all the time — and no one will believe their happily ever after.
• Like goal and motivation, conflict can change through out the book. One thing that makes conflict different however, is that conflict escalates during the plot. Conflict is what drives your plot. That big black moment? That’s conflict. So whatever your conflict is, make sure you can sustain it throughout the story.
• Conflict is what keeps the reader guessing. In my book Be Mine Tonight, I’ve been told I did a great job of this, though I couldn’t tell you how. In it the hero is sitting by the heroine’s bed watching her die. He has the power to save her, but his own internal conflict keeps him from acting and she fades into darkness. Does he save her? I’m not telling — no spoilers! lol. But we all know that to be a romance there has to be a happy ending, and I was amazed at how many readers have told me they believed the heroine was dead and gone. That’s conflict. It’s also a great fluke, but I’m more than happy to take credit.
• Misunderstanding is *not* conflict. If your conflict can be solved by the hero and heroine having a conversation then you do not have conflict. Take the secret baby plot. All the woman has to do is say, “I had your baby” or “I’m pregnant.” Works in real life. So why doesn’t she? If she’s afraid he’ll take the baby from her you’d better back that up with making him the kind of man who would do just that. Good luck making him hero material as well.
• Conflict is what forces your characters to grow and change. By overcoming obstacles they become better people. Unless of course, they’re the villian, in which case being constantly defeated may make he/she a worse person. Since conflict propels your plot, you can say that it also propels your character arc. Everything he faced made Luke Skywalker a different person. He grew, became a stronger Jedi, learned to control his anger and impulsive behavior. At least one of your characters (usually the hero) should be significantly altered by the end of the book. His life is fuller, has more meaning. He has realized what is important, and that’s all because of the conflicts he faced in winning the heroine’s heart.
That wraps up Craft 101-Goal, Motivation and Conflict. Any thoughts or questions? Any great examples of GMC you’d like to share from favorite books or movies? This is where I’ll plug Debra Dixon’s book “GMC: Goal, Motivation and Conflict, the building blocks of good fiction” and tell you to get a copy if you don’t already have one. It really does make sense of the whole process.
It’s after midnight, my book is coming out (buy it! lol) and I’m brain dead. Please excuse any spelling errors. I couldn’t find the spell check…
Kathryn, even if you think you’re “brain dead”, your three cogent essays have been extremely helpful. Thanks so much for sharing.
As an aside, I read Be Mine Tonight last summer by a pool in Las Vegas. It was sunny and a million degrees, but you made me feel the darkness, LOL! Unfortunately between the sun block, the pool water and the tropical rum drinks, the book fell apart in my hands, but I read it in its chunks!
January 30th, 2007 at 7:54 amGod bless you for these three craft blogs, Kate! They are exactly what I need…especially conflict. I don’t know why I have such a hard time letting my characters make mistakes! Nobody’s perfect and neither should my hero and/or heroine be.
Thanks so much.
And everyone should RUN out and buy NIGHT OF THE HUNTRESS today!!! It is a fabulous book with lots of sizzling romance, edge-of-your-seat action and HAWT love scenes! Get thee to a bookstore…NOW! LOL!
January 30th, 2007 at 8:15 amThis is so true, Kate. I finished my final editing of my first book, but then a “little bird” whispered that there wasn’t a good conflict between the hero/heroine. So I’ll go back and do major revisions at some future date, say five years from now?
Just kidding! But yes it does make perfect sense to have a conflict, otherwise there is no growth.
Thanks for your blog today, i learned a lot.
Michelle
January 30th, 2007 at 10:22 amThanks, ladies! I’m glad that you feel these blogs have been useful. And thank Maggie, book destroyer, for the gracious praise and Andrea for …well, just being Andrea.
Michelle, you won’t want to wait five years! lol. I still struggle with conflict, so don’t think you’re alone.
January 30th, 2007 at 11:05 amI’ve been having a blast racheting up the conflict in my ms. Love conflict! w00t!
And it’s new-book day!
January 30th, 2007 at 11:18 amGreat post, Kathryn. I’m like you, Andrea. I don’t like making my characters suffer. I try to keep my eye on the HEA.
January 30th, 2007 at 1:20 pmFirst things first, congratulations on what I know will be another “cannot put this book down” read. Hugs and congrats!
I’m hoping to get my copy as early as this evening after work
I love today’s blog. As a newbie I’m also struggling with how much conflict to put into my story. So am I getting this right? There has to be a “main” conflict to the story? Or can it change to, say, another type of conflict?
January 30th, 2007 at 1:27 pmIsabel, I hope you enjoy the book! And yes, there needs to be a main conflict in the book. It can be the conflict between hero and heroine or something they have to face together. If it is something they face together then there needs to be conflict between them as well. For example, there’s a demon on the loose (eek!) and the heroine is a vampire who can stop it, but no alone. She needs the help of the demon/vampire slayer hero. They have conflict with the demon, but also between themselves because she is everything he abhors and vice versa.
January 30th, 2007 at 6:16 pmDid anyone else buy Kathryn’s book yet??? I can’t wait to get it!!
When creating conflict… it is sometimes hard for me to stay away from cliches….. and if I do land on a cliche, I feel like I need a better way of making the archetype my own. I’m not sure there is an answer for that.. only maybe try to be more creative? I think I could fill a book with cliched conflicts really easily… Any words of wisdom on avoiding them?
Thanks Kathryn… this is the best.. and I’ve printed everything out.. I hope you are still around.. it was one of those days …lol…
January 30th, 2007 at 8:33 pmLaura, if you find yourself facing a cliche, do the opposite of what it would do. lol. The best idea is to keep it simple. A lot of times we want to write complicated stuff, but it’s the characters that all that stuff happen. Keep your plot fairly simple and then your characters have more room to breathe.
Would you like to post an example of one of your cliches and I’ll take a stab at it? Or, you can email me.
Hope you enjoy the book when you get it.
January 30th, 2007 at 10:18 pm