Feb
Using Your Gut Instincts in Your Writing Career
Keeping fingers crossed that this blog will work out better than the last one… *g*
Some of you may have had a chance to take a look at the interview Haven did with me and posted on her website recently. If so, you saw that I commented on the worst advice I’d ever received in terms of my writing career.
However, I have another little anecdote from around the same time - a little earlier than that disastrous incident, in fact - where I did listen to my instincts with some great results, even though I was still nervous and afraid in the process of it. It’s as powerful an example of following your instincts as the one detailed in the interview, only showing the positive things that can come from following your instincts (which I think is only fair). *g*
I was attending my first RWA National Conference in 1994, and boy, was I star-struck! I was surrounded by thousands of other romance writers and catching glimpses of authors whose books lined my own shelves at home (Barbara Samuel, Anne Stuart, Nora Roberts, Susan Wiggs, etc. I even had my picture taken with Diana Gabaldon, who was still attending RWA at that point in her career). Better still, I was able to attend “Spotlight On” workshops for the publishers I’d recently begun to target as most desirable for my own writing submissions; at the top of the list at that time was Bantam, the publisher of my absolute favorite author, Teresa Medeiros. A whole panel of editors from Bantam was there, along with Bantam Publisher Irwyn Applebaum and several other higher-ups from the company, since the conference was right in NYC and easily accessible for all of them.
I sat and listened avidly through the presentation, excited when they put on a slide show that gave everyone glimpes inside the Bantam offices, and trying not to get discouraged when they showed the room at Bantam dedicated solely to slush pile submissions, stacked waist-high all around with manuscripts and partials sent by hopefuls just like me.
Finally, after a question and answer session, the workshop ended, and people were milling around. It had been heavily attended, and there were at several hundred conference-goers all stretching, approaching some of the panelists, or heading out the doors to the next workshop on their schedules. I looked up, still overwhelmed by all that I’d seen and heard, and I saw that one of the Bantam editors wasn’t being mobbed by anyone. She was standing and shuffling through her papers, in preparation to leave the room. I felt a tingle of nervousness combined with a positive rush of feeling (my gut instinct) as I stood and prepared to approach her to ask the question I’d been too shy to ask in front of everyone during the question and answer session - a question I believed would be a great lead for me and my writing career, if I could get someone “in the know” to answer it.
Now, keep in mind that I was a young, naive, and inexperienced conference-goer, not to mention a brand new writer, having just begun my first manuscript about a year earlier. The question I asked wasn’t inappropriate, exactly, but it was probably a more direct question than any this big-time editor had ever had tossed at her before by a pip-squeak like me.
I marched right up to the to slightly raised dais and the table there where she was standing and told her I was an aspiring author who would love to write for Bantam books. Then I asked her if she could recommend any literary agents with whom she liked to work.
For an instant, she stared at me like I was from another planet, startled, I’m sure. Then this sort of half-smile quirked her lips, and her eyes warmed up. She exchanged glances with an assistant editor who’d come up next to her as I’d approached, murmured for her to hand her a pen, grabbed a piece of the hotel’s notepaper - it was Marriott Marquis letterhead - and scribbled five names in a list for me. With another glance by the assistant and a few murmurings between them, the editor handed the paper over to me, smiling even more deeply when I stumbled over myself thanking her before backing away in a daze.
I still have that paper, tucked away safely in my files - and I’m also represented by one of the agents/agencies on that list, though it was a long, hard road getting there (five years later, to be precise).
But that incident and that piece of paper remind me that it’s always right to follow your gut instincts when it comes to this writing life - just as it’s always a bad idea to ignore them.
And now, my question for the day, toward the prize being offered this week, is: what alternative career did I consider before settling on writing and teaching? (the answer can be found in the “Meet Mary” section of my website).
–MRM
Wow, that’s really an inspiring story. Imagine that you had the guts to go up and ask that. I can’t imagine doing anything like that (but then I’m horribly shy). But kudos to you for daring!
I missed being here for yesterday’s blog, and I just wanted to mention that I appreciate the advice on the rejections. I’m sure it’ll be tough, and it helps to be reminded to use the rejections in a better way.
Finally, thank you for being here this week and sharing your wisdom
February 20th, 2006 at 5:34 pmEmily
Hi Mary,
I’m not a writer but I’m popping by to say what a great interview!
Eve
February 20th, 2006 at 7:45 pmMary, reading about your experience at the conference left me with butterflies in my tummy. I echo Emmie’s words really gutsy but I’m glad it paid off.
I read your interview with Haven and I could just imagine how apprehensive you were after that episode.
This is a wonderful story and one that obviously ending in a happy ending… Do you ever imagine “what if” you’d decided not to ask the question to this editor?
Isabel
Eve ~ Once again thanks for coming by!
February 20th, 2006 at 8:51 pmThanks Emmie, Eve, and Isabel for the comments (and Eve, thanks for popping over to say hello!

You know, looking back on it now, I’m surprised I had to gumption to approach that editor, too. But I really was pretty new to the industry - and my mother has told me that I was always the kid in the classroom raising my hand to ask questions all the time on field trips, LOL - so I guess having the push to do something like that has some natural origin in me.
I do sometimes wonder “What if?” I hadn’t gone up and asked her that question. But you know, even back then I heard over and over that no agent is better than a bad agent, and I was really concerned about how to “know” if an agent was a good one or not. I figured what better way to find out than to go straight to the source! I’d have never called Bantam and asked that (though you CAN call and ask who represents a particular author whose work you like). But since the opportunity presented itself at that conference, I’m so glad I took it.
See you guys here tomorrow, with a new blog topic!
February 20th, 2006 at 9:11 pm–MRM
Do you have to answer on the day of the blog? I’m still confused.
Answer: National Security
February 21st, 2006 at 3:03 pmWow, well speaking from a former-and-still-at-times-in-large-crowds-wallflower, that’s incredible!
Yes Mary, you need to go with your gut instinct at times. It sounds like it’s a long road to become a published author, but you have to trust yourself and your intincts. :S Thanks!
Michelle
February 21st, 2006 at 4:34 pmThanks, everyone, for all the comments.
And no, dorothy, I don’t think you need to answer on the day of the blog. Isabel? Maybe you can clear that one up.
And dorothy, you’re the first to answer the question from the “Gut Instincts” blog that I can tell.
February 21st, 2006 at 4:48 pm–MRM
Sorry for the late response! To answer Dorothy’s and Mary’s question. You do not need to answer on the same day. As long as you answer the questions by Sunday, Feb 26, 2006.
Don’t be shy, we’re happy to have you participate. Everyone is welcome. Good luck to all the contestants.
Isabel
February 22nd, 2006 at 10:47 am